package chamelon

  1. Overview
  2. Docs

Source file fs_internal.ml

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
open Lwt.Infix

module Make(Shimmed_block : Block_ops.Block_shim) = struct
  type lookahead = {
    offset : int;
    blocks : int64 list ;
  }
  type t = {
    block : Shimmed_block.t;
    block_size : int;
    program_block_size : int;
    lookahead : lookahead ref;
    file_size_max : Cstruct.uint32;
    name_length_max : Cstruct.uint32;
    new_block_mutex : Lwt_mutex.t;
  }
  type blockpair = int64 * int64
  type directory_head = blockpair
  type key = Mirage_kv.Key.t

  type write_result = [ `No_space | `Split | `Split_emergency ]
  (* error type definitions straight outta mirage-kv *)
  type error = [
    | `Not_found           of key (** key not found *)
    | `Dictionary_expected of key (** key does not refer to a dictionary. *)
    | `Value_expected      of key (** key does not refer to a value. *)
  ]
  type write_error = [
    | error
    | `No_space                (** No space left on the device. *)
    | `Already_present of key (** The key is already present. *)
    | `Rename_source_prefix of key * key (** The source is a prefix of destination in rename. *)
  ]

  let root_pair = (0L, 1L)
  let pp_blockpair = Fmt.(pair ~sep:comma int64 int64)

  let log_src = Logs.Src.create "chamelon-fs-internal" ~doc:"chamelon FS internal layer"
  module Log = (val Logs.src_log log_src : Logs.LOG)

  module Read = struct

    (* get the wodge of data at this block number, and attempt to parse it *)
    let block_of_block_number {block_size; block; program_block_size; _} block_location =
      let cs = Cstruct.create block_size in
      Shimmed_block.read block block_location [cs] >>= function
      | Error b -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Block b)
      | Ok () ->
        match Chamelon.Block.of_cstruct ~program_block_size cs with
        | Error (`Msg s) ->
          Log.err (fun f -> f "error reading block %Ld : %s"
                      block_location s);
          Lwt.return @@ Error (`Chamelon `Corrupt)
        | Ok extant_block -> Lwt.return @@ Ok extant_block

    (* get the blocks at pair (first, second), parse them, and return whichever is more recent *)
    let block_of_block_pair t (l1, l2) =
      let open Lwt_result.Infix in
      Lwt_result.both (block_of_block_number t l1) (block_of_block_number t l2) >>= fun (b1, b2) ->
      Lwt.return @@ Ok (Chamelon.Block.latest b1 b2)

  end

  module Find : sig
    type blockwise_entry_list = blockpair * (Chamelon.Entry.t list)

    (** [all_entries_in_dir t head] gives an *uncompacted* list of all
     * entries in the directory starting at [head].
     * the returned entries in the directory are split up by block,
     * so the caller can distinguish between re-uses of the same ID number
     * when the directory spans multiple block numbers *)
    val all_entries_in_dir : t -> directory_head ->
      (blockwise_entry_list list, [ `Not_found of key ]) result Lwt.t

    (** [entries_of_name t head name] scans [head] (and any subsequent blockpairs in the directory's
     * hardtail list) for `id` entries matching [name]. If an `id` is found for [name],
     * all entries matching `id` from the directory are returned (compacted). *)
    val entries_of_name : t -> directory_head -> string -> (blockwise_entry_list list,
                                                           [`No_id of string
                                                           | `Not_found of key]
                                                          ) result Lwt.t

    (** [find_first_blockpair_of_directory t head l] finds and enters
     *  the segments in [l] recursively until none remain.
     *  It returns [`No_id s] if an entry for [s] is not present,
     *  [`Not_directory s] if an entry for [s] is present,
     *  but does not represent a valid directory. *)
    val find_first_blockpair_of_directory : t -> directory_head -> string list ->
      [ `Final_dir_on of directory_head
      | `No_id of string
      | `Not_directory of string ] Lwt.t

    val get_directory_head : t -> directory_head -> string -> (directory_head option,
                                                               [ `Not_found of key ]
                                                              ) result Lwt.t

  end = struct
    type blockwise_entry_list = blockpair * (Chamelon.Entry.t list)

    (* nb: all does mean *all* here; the list is returned uncompacted,
     * so the caller may have to compact to avoid reporting on expired state *)
    let rec all_entries_in_dir t block_pair =
      Read.block_of_block_pair t block_pair >>= function
      | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Not_found Mirage_kv.Key.empty)
      | Ok block ->
        let this_blocks_entries = Chamelon.Block.entries block in
        match Chamelon.Block.hardtail block with
        | None -> Lwt.return @@ Ok [(block_pair, this_blocks_entries)]
        | Some nextpair ->
          all_entries_in_dir t nextpair >>= function
          | Ok entries -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ((block_pair, this_blocks_entries) :: entries)
          | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Not_found Mirage_kv.Key.empty)

    let entries_of_name t block_pair name =
      let entries_of_id entries id =
        let matches (tag, _chunk) = (0 = compare tag.Chamelon.Tag.id id &&
                                tag.Chamelon.Tag.length < Chamelon.Tag.Magic.deleted_tag)
        in
        List.find_all matches entries
      in
      let id_of_key entries key =
        let module DataMap = Map.Make(Cstruct) in
        let data_matches c = 0 = String.(compare key @@ Cstruct.to_string c) in
        let tag_matches t =
          Chamelon.Tag.(fst t.type3 = LFS_TYPE_NAME) &&
          Chamelon.Tag.(snd t.type3 = 0x01 || snd t.type3 = 0x02) &&
          Chamelon.Tag.(t.length != Magic.deleted_tag)
        in
        let map = DataMap.empty in
        (* we need to be sure to grab the *last* matching tag from the entry set *)
        let map =
          List.fold_left (fun map (tag, data) ->
              if tag_matches tag && data_matches data then
                DataMap.add data tag.Chamelon.Tag.id map
              else map
            ) map entries
        in
        DataMap.find_opt (Cstruct.of_string key) map
      in
      let open Lwt_result in
      all_entries_in_dir t block_pair >>= fun entries_by_block ->
      let entries_matching_name (block, entries) =
        match id_of_key (Chamelon.Entry.compact entries) name with
        | None ->
          Log.debug (fun m -> m "id for %S not found in %d entries from %a"
                         name (List.length entries) pp_blockpair block);
          Error (`No_id name)
        | Some id ->
          Log.debug (fun m -> m "name %S is associated with id %d on blockpair %a"
                         name id pp_blockpair block);
          let entries = entries_of_id entries id in
          Log.debug (fun m -> m "found %d entries for id %d in %a"
                         (List.length entries) id pp_blockpair block);
          let tags = List.map fst entries in
          Log.debug (fun m -> m "here are the tags for the entries for id %d: %a"
                        id
                        Fmt.(list Chamelon.Tag.pp) tags);
          let compacted = Chamelon.Entry.compact entries in
          Log.debug (fun m -> m "after compaction, %d entries for id %d in %a"
                         (List.length compacted) id pp_blockpair block);
          Ok (block, compacted)
      in
      let blockwise_matches = List.filter_map (fun es ->
          match entries_matching_name es with
          | Ok (_, []) | Error _ -> None
          | Ok (block, l) -> Some (block, l)
        ) entries_by_block in
      Lwt.return (Ok blockwise_matches)

    let get_directory_head t block_pair name =
      entries_of_name t block_pair name >>= function
      | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
      | Ok l ->
        let get_dirs = List.filter_map Chamelon.Dir.of_entry in
        match List.map (fun (_block, dirs) -> get_dirs dirs) l |> List.flatten with
        | [] -> Lwt.return @@ Ok None
        | a::[] -> Lwt.return @@ Ok (Some a)
        | l ->
          let last = List.rev l |> List.hd in
          Log.debug (fun f -> f "directory at %a had multiple directory entries for key %s. choosing the last one, which points to %a"
                        pp_blockpair block_pair name pp_blockpair last);
          Lwt.return @@ Ok (Some last)

    let rec find_first_blockpair_of_directory t block_pair key =
      match key with
      | [] -> Lwt.return @@ `Final_dir_on block_pair
      | next::remaining ->
        get_directory_head t block_pair next >>= function
        | Ok None -> Lwt.return @@ `No_id next
        | Ok (Some next_directory_head)  ->
          find_first_blockpair_of_directory t next_directory_head remaining
        | Error _e -> Lwt.return @@ `No_id next

  end
  module Traverse : sig
    val follow_links : t -> blockpair list -> Chamelon.Entry.link ->
      (int64 list, Shimmed_block.error) result Lwt.t

    val last_block : t -> blockpair -> (blockpair,
                                       [`Block of Shimmed_block.error |
                                        `Chamelon of [> `Corrupt] ]) result Lwt.t

  end = struct
    let rec get_ctz_pointers t l index pointer =
      match l, index with
      | Error _ as e, _ -> Lwt.return e
      | Ok l, 1 -> Lwt.return @@ Ok (pointer :: l)
      | Ok l, index ->
        let open Lwt_result.Infix in
        let data = Cstruct.create t.block_size in
        Shimmed_block.read t.block pointer [data] >>= fun ()->
        let pointers, _data_region = Chamelon.File.of_block index data in
        match pointers with
        | [] -> Lwt.return @@ Ok (pointer::l)
        | next::_ -> get_ctz_pointers t (Ok (pointer::l)) (index - 1) (Int64.of_int32 next)

    let rec follow_links t visited = function
      | Chamelon.Entry.Data (pointer, length) -> begin
          let file_size = Int32.to_int length in
          let index = Chamelon.File.last_block_index ~file_size ~block_size:t.block_size in
          Log.debug (fun f -> f "data block: last block index %d found starting at %ld (0x%lx)" index pointer pointer);
          get_ctz_pointers t (Ok []) index (Int64.of_int32 pointer)
        end
      | Chamelon.Entry.Metadata (a, b) ->
        match List.mem (a, b) visited with
        | true -> Log.err (fun f -> f "cycle detected: blockpair %a encountered again after initial visit." pp_blockpair (a, b));
          Lwt.return @@ Error `Disconnected
        | false ->
          Read.block_of_block_pair t (a, b) >>= function
          | Error (`Block e) ->
            Log.err (fun m -> m
                        "block-level error reading block pair %Ld, %Ld (0x%Lx, 0x%Lx): %a"
                        a b a b Shimmed_block.pp_error e);
            Lwt.return @@ Error e
          | Error (`Chamelon `Corrupt) ->
            Log.err (fun f -> f
                        "filesystem seems corrupted; we couldn't make sense of a block pair");
            Lwt.return @@ Error `Disconnected
          | Ok block ->
            Log.debug (fun f -> f "finding blocks linked from %a" pp_blockpair (a, b));
            let links = Chamelon.Block.linked_blocks block in
            Log.debug (fun f -> f "found %d linked blocks" (List.length links));
            Lwt_list.fold_left_s (fun so_far link ->
                match so_far with
                | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
                | Ok l ->
                  follow_links t ((a, b)::visited) link >>= function
                  | Error e ->
                    Log.err (fun f -> f
                                "FILESYSTEM CORRUPTION. error following outbound links \
                                 from blockpair %a: %a"
                                pp_blockpair (a, b)
                                Shimmed_block.pp_error e);
                    Lwt.return @@ Error `Disconnected
                  | Ok new_links -> Lwt.return @@ Ok (new_links @ l)
              ) (Ok []) links
            >>= function
            | Ok list -> Lwt.return @@ Ok (a :: b :: list)
            | e -> Lwt.return e

    (* [last_block t pair] returns the last blockpair in the hardtail
     * linked list starting at [pair], which may well be [pair] itself *)
    (* write operations should target the returned blockpair *)
    let rec last_block t pair =
      let open Lwt_result.Infix in
      Read.block_of_block_pair t pair >>= fun block ->
      match List.find_opt (fun e ->
          Chamelon.Tag.is_hardtail (fst e)
        ) (Chamelon.Block.entries block) with
      | None -> Lwt.return @@ Ok pair
      | Some entry -> match Chamelon.Dir.hard_tail_links entry with
        | None -> Lwt.return @@ Ok pair
        | Some next_pair -> last_block t next_pair
  end
  module Allocate = struct
    let rec unused t used_blocks : (unit, [ `No_space ]) result =
      let module IntSet = Set.Make(Int64) in
      let actual_blocks = Shimmed_block.block_count t.block in
      let prev_offset = !(t.lookahead).offset in
      let alloc_size = max 16 ((min 256 actual_blocks) / 4) in
      let this_offset =
        if (prev_offset + alloc_size) >= Shimmed_block.block_count t.block then 0
        else prev_offset + alloc_size
      in
      Log.debug (fun f -> f "trying to find free blocks. %d were reported in-use out of %d"
                    (List.length used_blocks) actual_blocks);
      Log.debug (fun f -> f "will try to initialize %d starting at %d"
                    alloc_size this_offset);
      let pool = IntSet.of_list @@ List.init alloc_size
          (fun a -> Int64.of_int @@ a + this_offset)
      in
      let candidate = IntSet.(elements @@ diff pool (of_list used_blocks)) in
      if List.length candidate < 2 && (actual_blocks - (List.length used_blocks)) > 2 then begin
        (* that's not enough blocks, and we know there are more. go find them *)
        t.lookahead := { !(t.lookahead) with offset = this_offset };
        match unused t (used_blocks @ candidate) with
        | Ok () ->
          t.lookahead := { !(t.lookahead) with blocks = candidate @ !(t.lookahead).blocks};
          Ok ()
        | Error _ ->
          Error `No_space
      end else if (List.length candidate) >= 2 then begin
        t.lookahead := { !(t.lookahead) with offset = this_offset };
        t.lookahead := { !(t.lookahead) with blocks = candidate };
        Ok ()
      end else
        Error `No_space

    let populate_lookahead ~except t =
      Traverse.follow_links t [] (Chamelon.Entry.Metadata root_pair) >|= function
      | Error e ->
        Log.err (fun f -> f "error attempting to find unused blocks: %a" Shimmed_block.pp_error e);
        Error `No_space
      | Ok used_blocks ->
        Log.debug (fun f -> f "%d blocks used: %a" (List.length used_blocks) Fmt.(list ~sep:sp uint64) used_blocks);
        Ok (unused t (used_blocks @ except))

    let get_blocks t n : (int64 list, write_error) result Lwt.t =
      let get_block t =
        let l = !(t.lookahead).blocks in
        t.lookahead := {!(t.lookahead) with blocks = (List.tl l)};
        Lwt.return @@ Ok (List.hd l)
      in
      (* zero or fewer blocks is a pretty easy request to fulfill *)
      if n <= 0 then Lwt.return @@ Ok []
      else begin
        let rec aux t acc n =
          match !(t.lookahead).blocks with
          (* if we have exactly enough blocks, just return the whole list *)
          | l when List.length l = n ->
            t.lookahead := {!(t.lookahead) with blocks = []};
            Lwt.return @@ Ok (l @ acc)
          (* if we have enough in the lookahead buffer, just grab the first one n times *)
          | l when List.length l > n -> begin
              let l = List.init n (fun a -> a) in
              Lwt_list.fold_left_s (fun acc _ ->
                  match acc with | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
                                 | Ok l -> begin
                                     get_block t >>= function
                                     | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
                                     | Ok b -> Lwt.return @@ Ok (b::l)
                                   end
                ) (Ok acc) l
            end
          | l ->
            (* this is our sad case: not enough blocks in the lookahead allocator
                    to satisfy the request.
               Claim the blocks that are there already, and try to get more;
               if the allocator can't give us any, give up *)
            Log.debug (fun f -> f "wanted %d blocks, but the lookahead allocator only has %d"
                          n (List.length l));
            let open Lwt_result.Infix in
            populate_lookahead ~except:(l @ acc) t >>= function
            | Error `No_space ->
              Log.err (fun f -> f "no blocks remain free on filesystem");
              Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
            | Ok () ->
              aux t (l @ acc) (n - (List.length l))
        in
        aux t [] n
      end

    (* [get_block_pair fs] wraps [get_blocks fs 2] to return a pair for the caller's convenience *)
    let get_block_pair t =
      get_blocks t 2 >|= function
      | Ok (block1::block2::_) -> Ok (block1, block2)
      | Ok _ | Error _ -> Error `No_space

  end
  module Write = struct
    (* from the littlefs spec, we should be checking whether
     * the on-disk data matches what we have in memory after
     * doing this write. Then if it doesn't, we should rewrite
     * to a different block, and note the block as bad so we don't
     * try to write to it in the future.
     *
     * I don't think that's necessary in our execution context.
     * we're not writing directly to a flash controller,
     * we're probably writing to a file on another filesystem
     * managed by an OS with its own bad block detection.
     * That's my excuse for punting on it for now, anyway. *)
    let block_to_block_number t data block_location : (unit, write_result) result Lwt.t =
      let block_device = t.block in
      Shimmed_block.write block_device block_location [data] >>= function
      | Ok () -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
      | Error e ->
        Log.err (fun m -> m "block write error: %a" Shimmed_block.pp_write_error e);
        Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space

    let rec block_to_block_pair t data (b1, b2) : (unit, write_result) result Lwt.t =
      let split data  =
        Allocate.get_block_pair t >>= function
        | Error `No_space -> Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
        | Ok (new_block_1, new_block_2) when Int64.equal new_block_1 new_block_2 ->
          (* if there is only 1 block remaining, we'll get the same one twice.
           * That's not enough for the split. *)
          Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
        | Ok (new_block_1, new_block_2) -> begin
            Log.debug (fun m -> m "splitting block pair %Ld, %Ld to %Ld, %Ld"
                           b1 b2 new_block_1 new_block_2);
            let old_block, new_block = Chamelon.Block.split data (new_block_1, new_block_2) in
            Log.debug (fun m -> m "keeping %d entries in the old block, and putting %d in the new one"
                           (List.length @@ Chamelon.Block.entries old_block)
                           (List.length @@ Chamelon.Block.entries new_block));
            (* be very explicit about writing the new block first, and only overwriting
             * the old block pair if the new block pair write succeeded *)
            block_to_block_pair t new_block (new_block_1, new_block_2) >>= function
            | Error `Split | Error `Split_emergency | Error `No_space ->
              Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
            | Ok () -> begin
                Log.debug (fun f -> f "wrote new pair; overwriting old pair");
                (* ignore any warnings about needing to split, etc *)
                let cs1 = Cstruct.create t.block_size in
                let serialize = Chamelon.Block.into_cstruct ~program_block_size:t.program_block_size in
                match serialize cs1 old_block with
                | `Unwriteable ->
                  Log.err (fun f -> f
                              "unwriteable block during split operation: %a"
                              Chamelon.Block.pp old_block);
                  Lwt.return (Error `No_space)
                | `Split | `Split_emergency | `Ok ->
                  Lwt_result.both
                    (block_to_block_number t cs1 b1)
                    (block_to_block_number t cs1 b2) >>= function
                  | Ok ((), ()) -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
                  | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
              end
          end
      in
      let cs1 = Cstruct.create t.block_size in
      let serialize = Chamelon.Block.into_cstruct ~program_block_size:t.program_block_size in
      match serialize cs1 data with
      | `Ok -> begin
        Lwt_result.both
          (block_to_block_number t cs1 b1)
          (block_to_block_number t cs1 b2)
        >>= function
        | Ok _ -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
        | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
      end
      | `Split | `Split_emergency | `Unwriteable ->
        (* try a compaction first *)
        Cstruct.memset cs1 0x00;
        let compacted = Chamelon.Block.compact data in
        Log.debug (fun m -> m "split requested for a block with %d entries. compacted, we had %d"
                       (List.length @@ Chamelon.Block.entries data)
                       (List.length @@ Chamelon.Block.entries compacted)
                   );
        Log.debug (fun m -> m "@[entries pre-compaction:@ @[%a@]@]"
                      Fmt.(list ~sep:comma Chamelon.Entry.pp) (Chamelon.Block.entries data));
        Log.debug (fun m -> m "@[entries post-compaction:@ @[%a@]@]"
                      Fmt.(list ~sep:comma Chamelon.Entry.pp) (Chamelon.Block.entries compacted));
        match serialize cs1 compacted, Chamelon.Block.hardtail compacted with
        | `Ok, _ -> begin
            Log.debug (fun f -> f "compaction was sufficient. Will not split %a" pp_blockpair (b1, b2));
            Lwt_result.both
              (block_to_block_number t cs1 b1)
              (block_to_block_number t cs1 b2)
            >>= function
            | Ok _ -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
            | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
          end
        | `Split, None | `Split_emergency, None -> begin
            Log.debug (fun f -> f "compaction was insufficient and the block has no hardtail. Splitting %a" pp_blockpair (b1, b2));
            split compacted
          end
        | `Split, _ -> begin
            Log.debug (fun f -> f "split needed, but the block's already split. Writing the compacted block");
            Lwt_result.both
              (block_to_block_number t cs1 b1)
              (block_to_block_number t cs1 b2)
            >>= function
            | Ok _ -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
            | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
          end
        | `Split_emergency, _  | `Unwriteable, _ ->
          Log.err (fun f -> f "Couldn't write to block %a" pp_blockpair (b1, b2));
          Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
  end
  module Delete = struct
    let delete_in_directory directory_head t name =
      Find.entries_of_name t directory_head name >>= function
        (* several "it's not here" cases *)
      | Error (`No_id _) | Error (`Not_found _) ->
        Log.debug (fun m -> m "no id or nothing found for %s" name);
        Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
      | Ok [] | Ok ((_,[])::_) ->
        Log.debug (fun m -> m "no entries on %a for %s"
                       pp_blockpair directory_head name);
        Lwt.return @@ Ok ()
      | Ok ((blockpair_with_id, hd::_tl)::_) ->
        let id = Chamelon.Tag.((fst hd).id) in
        Log.debug (fun m -> m "id %d found for name %s on block %a" id name
                   pp_blockpair blockpair_with_id);
        Read.block_of_block_pair t blockpair_with_id >>= function
        | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Not_found (Mirage_kv.Key.v name))
        | Ok block ->
          Log.debug (fun m -> m "adding deletion for id %d on block pair %a"
                         id pp_blockpair blockpair_with_id);
          let deletion = Chamelon.Tag.delete id in
          let new_block = Chamelon.Block.add_commit block [(deletion, Cstruct.empty)] in
          Write.block_to_block_pair t new_block blockpair_with_id >>= function
          | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
          | Ok () -> Lwt.return @@ Ok ()

  end

  let mkdir_nonrec t containing_directory_head new_directory_name =
    (* first, make sure this name isn't already in this directory *)
    Find.entries_of_name t containing_directory_head new_directory_name >>= function
    | Ok (hd::tl) -> begin
      (* do any of the entries represent a valid directory entry? if so, we don't need to do anything *)
      (* TODO: the blockwise entry list returned by `entries_of_name` is pretty annoying to work with *)
      let get_dirs = List.filter_map Chamelon.Dir.of_entry in
      let dirs = List.map (fun (_block, dirs) -> get_dirs dirs) (hd::tl) |> List.flatten in
      match List.rev dirs with
      | pair::_ -> Lwt.return (Ok pair)
      | _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Already_present new_directory_name)
    end
    | Error (`No_id _) | Error (`Not_found _) | Ok [] ->
      Traverse.last_block t containing_directory_head >>= function
      | Error (`Chamelon (`Corrupt)) ->
        Log.err (fun f -> f "FS CORRUPTION SUSPECTED: mkdir attempt failed. it was not possible to find the last block \
                             in the directory whose head is at %a"
                    pp_blockpair containing_directory_head);
        Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
      | Error (`Block e) ->
        Log.err (fun f -> f "block-level error encountered attempting to find last block in the directory whose head is at %a: %a"
                    pp_blockpair containing_directory_head Shimmed_block.pp_error e);
        Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
      | Ok last_pair_in_containing_directory ->
        (* create a new entry for a directory `new_directory_name` in `pair` *)
        Log.debug (fun f -> f "found last pair %a in directory starting at %a"
                      pp_blockpair last_pair_in_containing_directory
                      pp_blockpair containing_directory_head);
        (* we expect to alter the structure of last_pair_in_containing_directory,
         * so make sure we can make sense of it to begin with *)
        Read.block_of_block_pair t last_pair_in_containing_directory >>= function
        | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Not_found (Mirage_kv.Key.v new_directory_name))
        | Ok containing_directory_last_block_content ->
          (* we need a block pair on which the new directory will have its head *)
          (* since we need to hold on to these blocks until they're reachable from the root blockpair,
           * this whole thing needs to be within the `new_block_mutex` *)
          Lwt_mutex.with_lock t.new_block_mutex @@ fun () -> begin
            Allocate.get_block_pair t >>= function
            | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`No_space)
            | Ok new_pair ->
              (* first, write empty commits to the new blockpair; if that fails,
               * we want to bail before making any more structure
               * point anyway *)
              Write.block_to_block_pair t (Chamelon.Block.of_entries ~revision_count:1l []) new_pair >>= function
              | Error _ ->
                Log.err (fun f -> f "error initializing a directory at a fresh block pair %a"
                            pp_blockpair new_pair);
                Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
              | Ok () ->
                (* finally, we're ready to add our new directory to the contents of the containing directory *)
                let extant_ids = Chamelon.Block.ids containing_directory_last_block_content in
                (* TODO: it's definitely possible to manipulate this such that you overflow *)
                let new_dir_id = match Chamelon.Block.IdSet.max_elt_opt extant_ids with
                  | None -> 1
                  | Some s -> s + 1
                in
                let name = Chamelon.Dir.name new_directory_name new_dir_id in
                let dirstruct = Chamelon.Dir.mkdir ~to_pair:new_pair new_dir_id in
                let containing_directory_updated_last_block =
                  Chamelon.Block.add_commit containing_directory_last_block_content [name; dirstruct]
                in
                Write.block_to_block_pair t
                  containing_directory_updated_last_block last_pair_in_containing_directory
                >>= function
                | Error _ -> Lwt.return @@ Error `No_space
                | Ok () -> Lwt.return @@ Ok new_pair
          end

  let rec get_directory ~ensure_path t root segments =
    match segments with
    | [] -> Lwt.return @@ Ok root
    | next::l ->
      if ensure_path then begin
        (* `mkdir_nonrec` will return (Ok directory_head) if the directory already exists *)
        mkdir_nonrec t root next >>= function
          | Error _ as e -> Lwt.return e
          | Ok dir_head -> get_directory ~ensure_path t dir_head l
        end else begin
        (* in this case we shouldn't make it if it's not already there, so just go look for it *)
        Find.get_directory_head t root next >>= function
        | Error (`Not_found s) -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Not_found s)
        | Ok None -> Lwt.return @@ Error (`Not_found (Mirage_kv.Key.v next))
        | Ok (Some dir_head) -> get_directory ~ensure_path t dir_head l
      end
end